Armenian News Network /
Groong
Sultan Abdul
Hamid II: What did he really look like?
Caricatures versus photographs.
September
21, 2014
Special to Groong by Eugene L. Taylor
and Abraham D. Krikorian
Long Island, NY
Disclaimer Today, 21 September is supposedly Abdul
Hamids birthday – some sources say it was the 22nd- no
matter, close enough. We are the
last ones to note with any measure of appreciation or sincerity, much less celebrate,
his day of entry into the world in 1842.
We will, however, use the opportunity to expand on a few questions that
have been asked of us concerning the portrayal of the 34th Ottoman
Sultan in caricature and cartoons.
See e.g. Groong http://www.groong.org/orig/ak-20140318.html
on Papier dArmnie. Just what did he look like? Not an easy question to answer but we
shall try. |
---|
There is little disagreement that Sultan
Abdul Hamid II was a very important figure in the long and sad history of the
Armenians, but even today he remains more of a critically understudied and elusive
figure than one might imagine. The
late Armenian genocide denialist Professor Stanford J. Shaw described him as the
last great Ottoman Sultan (see Shaw, 1991 pg. 179). According to Shaw, his plans for doing
all sorts of wonderful things were impressive (see Shaw, 1973 for a shopping
or aspirations list). Oh? Cynics (realists?) such as ourselves
might even venture to say that an effort, albeit a useless one in our
not-so-humble opinion, has been made to rehabilitate Abdul Hamid IIs image (see
for example in addition to Shaw, Sever, 2010). Just what it was about administration
through massacre and Thy shalt not kill that the Red Sultan did not seem to
understand eludes us.
Because of
our interest in various aspects of imagery and photographs dealing with the
various persecutions of the Armenians, culminating in the Armenian Genocide,
we have asked ourselves a number of times How accurate, in the broadest sense
of the word, are the various depictions of the Sultan in caricature, cartoons, photographs
in books or illustrated articles and essays? We all know that a good caricaturist can
rain havoc on anyone. On the other hand,
some people are, simply put, a gift on a silver platter to the caricaturist and
cartoonist. Sultan Abdul Hamid II
was one of these, not just because of his appearance but because of his
dastardly deeds.
A more
important question might perhaps be whether there are photographs of this
infamous sultan that are attested, and better yet attributed?
Despite Sultan
Abdul Hamids supposed interest in photography (Allen, 1984; Micklewright, 2000;
Roberts, 2013 and references there cited), he himself seems to have been, for
various reasons including paranoia, very camera shy, if we care to put it
diplomatically. Few outsiders knew
what he really looked like. Note
the qualifications in the caption to the image below.
From The Junior Munsey vol. 9,
no. 1 October 1900 pg. 101.
We imagined at
one time that his bosom friend and alleged confidant Professor Arminus
Vambery might have enabled him to include an autographed or inscribed
presentation portrait of the Sultan in either tome of his 2 volume work The Story of My Struggles, The Memoirs of
Arminius Vambery (1904) [https://archive.org/details/storymystruggle00vmgoog].
No luck on
that front.
One of the
very few, perhaps the only truly close-up photograph that we have located and
feel fairly certain that its date is approximated more or less accurately is
the one found opposite pg. 159 in the memoir by Sultan Abdul Hamid IIs
daughter, the Princess Ach Osmanoglou (1887-1960) entitled Avec Mon Pre Le Sultan Abdulhamid de son
palais a sa prison (L'Harmattan, Paris 1991). The original version was translated from
Turkish into French. The caption
under the photograph reads in translation Sultan Abdulhamid II around the
middle of his reign — since he ascended 31 August 1876 and was deposed
27 April 1909 we may date the photograph around 1892 or 1893 or so. Born in 1842, he would have been about 50
years old.
This photograph
provides us with a reasonable fit since we have wanted to have a fairly
reliable image of the sultan around the period of the Hamidian massacres, say around
1894-1896. The caption goes on to
say He had allowed his beard to grow, following the tradition of the
sultans. The only sultans who did
not have a beard were Selim I, Osman II, Mourad V and Mehmed VI
Vahideddin. One should add at
least one more, namely Sultan Mehmed V, who was active, or more accurately inactive, during the Armenian Genocide
when the Young Turk hoodlums and criminals administered the Empire.
We
appreciate very much the kind permission to use this copyrighted photograph - Editions
lHarmattan (Paris).
http://www.editions-harmattan.fr/index.asp?navig=catalogue&obj=livre&no=5278
We have also
in our quest for images wondered whether there are hoards of photographs of
Sultan Abdul Hamid II in any of the various Ottoman Archives? When we saw the image used on a stamp (1.10
Turkish lira - around 50 cents U.S.) issued in 2013 by the so-called Republic
of Turkey featuring various Imperial palaces we wondered if there was any special
reason, other than the obvious propagandistic one so as to make him seem
benign, the one selected was used. Also,
he looks to us as rather pale-faced not swarthy as he apparently was (see below). Surely there had to be others from which a better selection might have been made? There were certainly royal photographers
approved by the Sultan.
For interested
independent researchers and publicists such as ourselves, most photographs or
images pertaining to almost everyone, and that includes Sultan Abdul Hamid II
of course, are at worst undated, or at best, incompletely or imprecisely
dated. Only a very few go so far as
to give a fairly precise time period.
One of the more interesting contemporary books, a now fairly rare volume
written by Will Seymour Monroe, entitled Turkey and the Turks (1907) has some
interesting photographs. The volume
includes a photograph that is well-known and has the added bit of information
that the Sultan is 34 — making the supposed date of the photograph 1876. It seemed safe to speculate that it dated
from the time of his enthronement. There
was one minor difficulty however, identical copies of the photograph exist that
show that photographers W. & D. Downey were responsible for the
photograph. The photograph was, we
are told by Roberts (2013, pg. 18) , taken in Buckingham Palace in London by William
Downey, Queen Victorias photographer in 1867! (Incidentally, we have also seen it
stated somewhere, we forget where, that it was at Balmoral Castle. Whatever.) Abdul Hamid was in England during the
summer of 1867 when as an Ottoman prince he accompanied his Uncle Sultan Abdul
Aziz to Europe, ultimately to attend the Exposition Universelle in Paris. There is a photograph of Prince Abdul
Hamid taken then that he kept as a calling card (carte de visite). He liked cartes de visites. His visage is younger than the one where
he is clad in royal finery. In any
case, it shows that there are opportunities to concern oneself, if one is so
inclined- which we are not in this case, to look into matters a bit more
deeply.
Another
photograph said to derive from 1868 is presented below. A copy of this may be found on
Wikipedia. He perhaps looks the same,
or younger or older than the one taken in 1867 in his imperial garb. In any case, it is a real
photograph. Too early to concern us
seriously here.
s
All this means is that the photograph
usually used to show him as SULTAN simply is not accurate.
It also seems that anyone interested in publishing a picture of the
Sultan, inevitably from outside the Empire, from that period onwards for
whatever purposes had to make do with the likes of the princely image in
costume well into the 1890s, without necessarily knowing or caring when the
photograph was taken. See below,
for example, a color version on the cover of Le Petit Journal (Supplment
Illustr) Paris 21 February 1897. In contrast, his Uncle Sultan Abdul Aziz
played photographs like a violin for publicity as the saying goes (Roberts,
2013 for details).
The Muse des Sires photo postcard below
shows the bloodied hands of the Sultan, and the princely photo could well have
served as a model for satirical purposes.
(There is, incidentally, a considerably larger (52 x 36 cm.) version in
Muse des Souverains, portfolio size collection.)
A similar caricature
portraying the sultan as the evil and wicked, sinister-looking murderer
dripping blood that he was, may be found on the cover of Le Rire (Paris) 29 May 1897 No. 134. This was drawn by the accomplished
artist Jean Veber who drew for the widely read satirical journals Assiette au Beurre and Le Rire etc. For an online version
dating from 1900 see also https://archive.org/stream/MuseeDesSouverains1900#page/n13/mode/2uph
The drawing
on the January 23, 1896 front page of The
Washington Post (the Post of
yesteryear, not nowadays) is rather crude, even amateurish, but shows some of
the features apparent in what we have presented above. No claim can be made that it represents
a particularly good likeness. The rendering
of Clara Barton is no masterpiece of fidelity either.
The same genre of imagery may be
found in The Rams Horn (published in
Chicago) below.
A cartoon,
originally published in Aptag [The
Slap] but taken here from Patmutiwn S.D.
Hnchakean Kusaktsutean: 1887-1962 [History of the Social Democratic
Hunchagian Party] shows a particularly gruesome scene. The Sultan is drawn in a fashion
reminiscent of the ones just shown.
We need not go into detail.
The message is clear. (For
anyone interested in Armenian caricatures etc. see Anahide Ter-Minassians 1995
excellent paper on the satirical drawings in the Armenian periodical Gavroche from 1908-1920.)
Below we see
images of the Sultan and his deposed brother Sultan Murad V (variously
described as alcoholic, feeble-minded, mentally deranged, suicidal etc.) and
his brother Prince Mehmed Reshid who would ascend upon Sultan Abdul Hamids
forced deposition to the Ottoman throne as Sultan Mehmed V (Imperial and Asiatic Quarterly Review 1,
1896 pg. 68). The two lower ones
appear to be real, not so with the one of Abdul Hamid II. Well dispense with this one as well.
A satirical rendering
of the Sultan, the Grand Turk, by Ėdouard Ppin from the cover of Le Grelot (No. 1351, Paris) 28 February
1897 capitalizes beautifully on Abdul Hamids prominent nose. He advises student protesters and
demonstrators chanting Long Live Crete, Long Live Greece (even as Armenia is
shown pushed downwards and suppressed violently), and advising that we should
be French [behave like true Frenchmen] and concern yourselves with what goes on
at your own borders! (Note German suppression of Alsace-Lorraine at the upper
left.)
With time, portrayal
of Sultan Abdul Hamid IIs nose seems to have become larger and a bit more
crooked (Dick Tracy-like?). The
image below is taken from a post card we own sarcastically labeling the Sultan
as the most spiritual of the tyrants but the same caricaturization also
appeared in LAssiette au Beurre no.
9 issued on 8 August 1901 in the series Les Souverains by Leal Da Camara, pg.
302. In that issue the talented Da
Camara is merciless on other sovereigns as well.
The same
type of sinister, even sanguine face may be seen at the left of the card
below. The claim is made that
chique, fashionable, men only wear
suspenders made by Betelle Ch. Guyot.
Sultan Abdul Hamid II, the butcher, is shown using said suspenders to
hold up his butchers apron. Just
why the apron appears clean and bloodless is anyones guess. The others, all sovereigns, use them to
hold up their trousers. Note the
pot-bellied King Edward VII of Great Britain on the far right.
The Sultans
nose is again and inevitably a feature in the image on the cover of LAssiette au Beurre 31 October
1903. The headline reads
Abdul-Hamid II, or Thirty Years of Assassinations or, as we prefer since it
is as defensible both in fact and translation of Murders.
A work
written by Georges Dorys, published in 1901 in English translation, includes a
frontispiece image of the Sultan.
Although it too seems to us not to be from a real photograph, it
presumably is fairly accurate.
Dorys got himself in trouble over his writings and was apparently
condemned to death should he ever showed up on Turkish territory. His father was the late Prince of Samos,
a former minister of the Sultan, and at one time Governor of Crete. As such Georges Dorys was held to be in
a good position to know a fair amount about the Sultans personality, and
presumably what he looked like. It
seems likely that this was used as a base by some of the caricaturists.
The
following caricatures that we have selected for use in this general overview focus
especially on the Armenian massacres.
The first, from LAssiette au
Beurre 16 August 1902 pg. 1199 more than alludes to the Sultans alleged Armenian
connection. The captions says And
if there is only one left, Ill be the one! [It adds on the lower right that The
Sultans mother was Armenian.]
The two-page bloody red and black caricature in the same issue which reads Bon appetit gentlemen shows the Ottoman ghoulish element at play or work? The upper head is that of Faik Bey the chamberlain, below him is that of Izzet the favorite, then the Sultan, and the bottom-most the Sultans secretary Tahsin Bey. Note the vampirish face and blood dripping from the Sultans bloody mouth in the enlargement.
The ever-conspicuous
huge, prominently crooked nose is a key element in this September 9, 1902 post
card image showing the Sultans head depicted as A Turkish hook in regular use
to butcher in Armenia. Just who the
artist Oreds was, has so far eluded us.
Paul de
Rglas Au pays de lespionnage
(Paris, 1902) shows Abdul Hamid leaving a bloody trail. The rendition of the face seems fairly
good, leaving the message as to the twin pistols and the bloody footprints to suggest
to the viewer his paranoia.
By 1908 we are
able to finally see a real photograph of the Sultan descending from his
carriage. This was on the cover of
the French weekly LIllustration 22
August 1908.
This photo
was also used considerably later on the cover of Yazigians volume in Armenian
on the Red Sultan. Aptiwl Hamit B., Karmir Sultane: Harakits
Osmanean patmutiwn ew hastatutiwnner
by Gurgen Yazechean [K. Yazidjian] published in 1980. This 871 page tome was printed in Beirut
(Peyrut : Tp. Sevan). [Excuse us once
more for using the ridiculous transliteration used in World Cat but this allows
anyone interested to find the volume in the world outside of Armenian
libraries.]
A fuller view
of the same scene that is rarely encountered is shown below. It derives from Sir Edwin Pears Forty Years in Constantinople (1916)
facing pg. 246. The shots above
were either cropped for publication or were taken at closer range.
Some later photographs
of the Sultan Abdul Hamid II which are dated exactly and attributed, at least
in part, exist. On the front cover
of the French illustrated weekly LIllustration
Saturday 8 August 1908 there is a photograph, clearly taken at a distance, and from
a high vantage point, of Sultan Abdul Hamid II, for the first time since his
ascension to the throne, avails himself to the curiosity of his subjects and
photographers.
This
photograph is a bit troublesome to us not only because it was taken at a distance,
but we believe that it is significant that in the same journal on 22 August
1908 the cover image of Sultan Abdul Hamid II shows him thinner, more
round-shouldered, his nose more prominent, his beard perhaps a bit more greyish
(?). Could stress have aged him
that much in a few weeks?
Apparently.
LAssiette au Beurre 29August 1908 presented a black-bearded,
suspicious-looking Sultan Abdul Hamid II wiping his bloody sword on the
sacrosanct Constitution, which to him was clearly only a piece of paper. A new era of regeneration for Turkey is at
hand! As the old time Armenian
immigrants used to say sarcastically Adel havadah- believe that too! No gullibility there.
It will also
be of some interest to quote from the same issue of LIllustration 8 August 1908 wherein an oval portrait taken from a
miniature of the Sultan states in its caption that this is the sole portrait of
the Sultan taken before the 31 July 1908 Selamlik photograph on the cover of
the issue from which we have made the scans and enlargements included here. The image was supposedly provided by the
Sultan himself for reproduction.
It further
states that all other images and portrayals should be considered to be apocryphal!
The last few
images we present here derive from Punch
in 1908 and 1909 and dont seem bad renditions to us as to what he may have
looked like. Perhaps they were
drawn with a real image(s) at hand?
The third one was first published in January 18, 1896 but was reissued
on December 16, 1914 in a collection called The Unspeakable Turk. Dj vu all over again? but with
different players.
Finally, we
see on the 15 May 1909 cover of Le Rire
a satirical rendition of Sultan Mehmed V perched on his brother Abdul Hamid
IIs corpse. The inescapable nose
sticks up in profile. In our
opinion, Charles Landres caricatures of the two sultan brothers is
brilliant. They capture the essence
of it all. How appropriate - except
brother Abdul Hamid was still alive and died of pneumonia in February 1918. You have to appreciate Mehmeds jowls.
We close by
asking does it really matter what they looked like? The deeds carried out in their name speak
volumes.
Acknowledgements
We thank Missak Kelechian for obtaining
for us some years ago a copy in Beirut of the Armenian volume on Sultan Hamid. There are few copies around with fresh,
unmarred covers. Thanks also to Ms.
Donna Sammis of Stony Brook University Library for help in obtaining through
Interlibrary Loan some materials to which we would otherwise not have had access. Scans were generally made from items
that we own.
Select Bibliography
Allen,
William (1984) The Abdul Hamid II
collection. History of Photography 8, no. 2, 119-145.
Anonymous.
(1908) In Constantinople 31 July
Photo by Weinberg. LIllustration (Paris) 66e
anne No. 3415 Samedi 8 Aot 1908.
Story pg. 104.
Mickelwright,
Nancy (2000) Personal, public and
political (re)constructions: photographs and consumption. In Consumption studies and the history
of the Ottoman Empire, 1550-1922: an introduction. Ed. by Donald Quataert). Albany: State University of New York
Press.
Monroe, W.
S. [Will Seymour] (1907) Turkey
and the Turks. An account of the lands, the peoples, and the institution of the
Ottoman Empire (Boston, L. Page and Co.,
Accessible online at https://archive.org/details/turkeyturksaccou00monrrich
Osmanoglou,
Aich (1991) Avec Mon Pre Le
Sultan Abdulhamid de son palais a sa prison. (Traduit de Turc par Jacques Jeulin). Ėditions L'Harmattan (Paris). See
http://www.editions-harmattan.fr/index.asp?navig=catalogue&obj=livre&no=5278
Pears, Sir Edwin (1916) Forty Years In Constantinople: the
recollections of Sir Edwin Pears (1873-1915). London: Jenkins.
https://archive.org/details/fortyyearsincons00peariala
Rgla, Paul de (1902) Au Pays de lespionnage: les sultans
Mourad V et Abd-ul-Hamid II. (Paris:
Librairie J. Strauss).
Roberts, Mary (2013) Ottoman statecraft and the Pencil of
Nature. Photography, painting, and
drawing at the court of Sultan Abdlaziz.
Ars Orientalis (Washington,
DC) 43, 11-30.
Sever, Aytek (2010) A Pan-Islamist in Istanbul: Jamal
ad-din Afghani and Hamidian Islamism, 1892-1897. A thesis submitted to the Graduate
School of Social Sciences of Middle East Technical University, Ankara. http://etd.lib.metu.edu.tr/upload/12612440/index.pdf
Shaw, Stanford.(1973) A promise of reform: two complimentary
documents. International Journal of Middle East Studies 4, 359-368.
Shaw, Stanford.(1991) Sultan Abdul Hamid II: last man of the Tanzimat,
pgs. 179-197; in Tanzimatin 150. Yildnm Uluslararasi Sempozyumu: bildiriler, 25-27 Aralik 1989, Milli Ktphane, Ankara. Edited
by Isin
Duruz and Gnl Byklimanli, Ankara: T.C. Kltr Bakanligi. Milli Ktphane
Baskanligi.
Ter-Minassian,
Anahide (1995) Les dessins
satiriques dans le priodique armnien Gavroche (1908-1920). REMM,
Revue du monde Mussulman et de la Mditerane No. 77-78, 123-143.
Vambery, Arminius (1904) The Story of My Struggles, The memoirs
of Arminius Vambry, Professor of Oriental languages in the University of
Budapest. London: T. Fisher Unwin, 2 volumes.
For volume 1 see https://archive.org/details/storymystruggle00vmgoog
Yazechean, Gurgen [Yazidjian, Kurken] (1980) Aptiwl Hamit B., Karmir Sultane:
Harakits Osmanean patmutiwn ew hastatutiwnner [Abdul Hamid, the Red Sultan:
a Comprehensive Ottoman History and Institutions], Beirut: Tp. Sevan..
Redistribution of Groong articles, such as this one, to any other
media, including but not limited to other mailing lists and Usenet
bulletin boards, is strictly prohibited without prior written
consent from Groong's Administrator.
Copyright 2014 Armenian News Network/Groong. All Rights Reserved. |
---|